Weindependently evaluateall of our recommendations . If you get across on links we offer , we may take in compensation .
After testing 27 options , we ’ve cut into up the dirt on the composters worth your metre and money .
In This Article
Better Homes & Gardens
compost can seem intimidate . After all , nutrient - rich compostis often refer to as “ mordant atomic number 79 , ” which can put air pressure on mass who are new to making their own to get it just correct . But if you may find the best compost ABA transit number for your needs — whether you ’re looking for something elementary to put on a kitchen countertop or a large bin to arrange up outdoors — composting can be way promiscuous than expected .
First thing ’s first : While any composting product is often referred to as a compost binful , there actually is a difference of opinion between a compost bank identification number and a composter . Bins plainly collect the compost and employ airtight seals and filter to prevent odors . On the other hand , composters break down the material into compost .
Credit:Better Homes & Gardens
But aside from lie with if you desire a countertop apparatus or something more complex , several factors go into finding the best compost bins . In gain to our testing , we spoke to three expert , Aaron Steil , a consumer gardening extension specialist for the Department of Horticulture at Iowa State University , and works expertsFern Bergof Tree Vitalize andAndy Taitof True Green Nursery to check more about what to look for in a composter or compost bin .
What We Tested
We tested compost bins and evaluated them on factors such as design , capacitance , odor control , quality , and value .
For more information on how we screen compost bins , watch outour testing processbelow .
Our Top Picks
Composter Type
Compost bins typically dish up as a collection point where you’re able to add in food scraps and other organic waste until it ’s meter to empty the bin into your outdoor compost pile or you extradite your scraps to a local wastefulness direction governance .
On the other hand , a composter help divulge down the waste into compostthat can be used toimprove filth healthin your garden . A composter needs heat , moisture , aeration ( from turning the compost on a regular basis ) , and time .
Ultimately , you may benefit from get a three - ABA transit number system , Steil says . you’re able to use a compost bin to collect combat , a composter to get out down the waste into compost , and a third container to store your fertiliser until you ’re ready to employ it .
Credit:Better Homes & Gardens
While you ’re shopping for a compost binful or composter you’re able to count different types , like tumble composters , compost systems that use worms , orindoor kitchen compost bin . The type you prefer can calculate on how much space you have , how much maintenance you ’re willing to take on , and even how much experience you have with compost .
tumble Composters
If you ’re new to compost , tumblers likeour top pick from Black+Decker“are a fairlyuser - friendly and effective method acting of composting that will be ideal for those with small- to average - sized gardens , where both kitchen dissipation and garden dissipation is available for composting , ” Berg says .
Credit: Amazon
Tumbling example spin the total deal to provide aeration so you do n’t need tokeep a rakeor shovel nearby . They also have the advantage of being fully enclose to keep out pests .
Berg adds , “ Just make indisputable you choose a beneficial quality mathematical product that uses a hardy framework as the ABA transit number will become very heavy once it is full . ”
Stationary Composters
Credit: Better Homes & Gardens
Stationary framework are the most round-eyed ( and often most affordable ) composters available . These home open compost pile , which may be ideal if you have an oversized garden or large compost heap .
Unlike tumbling composters or worm - ground options , you ’ll need to manually turn your compost pilewith a shovel , blood , orgarden forkto provide aeration . These open - aviation choice can also attract more pesterer and emit olfactory sensation .
Vermicomposting ( Worm - free-base Composting )
For those more familiar with compost or willing to put in more workplace to maintain their compost system , a louse - based system can be a great option that boil out some top - notch compost to make next class ’s veg better than ever .
“ Worm bins are an ideal compost solution for people who require to reuse their kitchen waste into gamy - quality compost and those with limited space , ” Berg says . “ They are higher maintenance than some of the other options so wo n’t be desirable for those who want a hands - off approach to compost . ”
Indoor Composters
Technically , indoor composters , or food recyclers , do n’t make real compost . However , the pre - compost mix they do produce offers a flock of the same benefit , like nourishing plant and reducing waste . We recommend using these as a style to break down food before adding it to a larger compost pile .
These galvanising machine heat the contents , then crunch and oxygenise them to get out them down . Typically , this process takes less than a day — much quicker than traditional compost .
Capacity
It ’s important to select the right size of it compost bin to meet your household ’s organic waste product and garden needs . A household with one or two people that is merely compile food scraps but wo n’t be using their own compost can get off with a smaller capacity bin , about 1 to 2 gallons .
Just keep in mind that even if you prefer for a large indoor binful as the undecomposed compost ABA transit number for your home , it still want to be empty regularly , at least once per week or so , to keep olfactory perception and pests at bay .
For outdoor composting , you ’ll need a space at least 3 x 3 x 3 foot for your bin or composter . Many outside bins start around 60 to 80 gallon , a unspoiled size for a small garden , with some models harbor several hundred congius of permissive waste . The largest compost product we include in our best compost bins tilt , theGeobin bin , has a capacity of 246 congius .
Location
A compost bank identification number can be set up indoors or outdoors , so you ’ll require to weigh if you have enough space to keep your composting system . diminished bin with tight - sealing lid can go on a kitchen counter or under the kitchen cesspool , hidden by behind a console door .
Outdoor setup typically require at least a three-dimensional yard of space , and Steil says its good for the compost arena to get some sunshine and some shade to keep the pile moist but not too coolheaded or lactating .
“ If it ’s in full sun , it ’s more potential to dry out out too quick , but if it ’s in full specter it ’s not likely to get warm enough and may stay wet too long , ” Steil explain .
Odor Control
Compost , when done correctly , should n’t have any foul olfactory sensation . It may not smack like much of anything , or it could have a pleasant , earthy flavour that may even be slightly sweet . Steil pronounce that if your compost pile stinks , it may be because the ratio of chocolate-brown to unripe material is off . While the ideal ratio can vary , you could aim for about 30 dark-brown to 1 green ; brown being carbon - rich material like stagnant leaves , sprig , or newspaper and green being nitrogen - rich matter like yield andvegetable scraps .
However , even with the correct proportion , indoor bins in exceptional can get a bit smelly since these are often project just to go for organic wastefulness until you could send it to a waste management facility or total it to your outdoor compost pile . To keep olfactory perception at bay , you’re able to look for add up features that trap or neutralize feeling .
“ Look for compost BIN with a charcoal filter or an airtight lid to facilitate immobilize unpleasant sense of smell , ” Tate state . “ The fusain filter suck odors and forestall them from escaping . Additionally , regularly turning and mixing the compost helps to activate it and reduce odors . ”
Best Tumbling Composter
Black+Decker Tumbling Composter
The dual chambers allow you to pile up waste on one side while simultaneously producing usable compost on the other side .
This is on the smaller side for an outdoor composter , so it may not be suitable for larger gardens .
Earning high marks across all categories by our examination team , theBlack+Decker latch on Composteris one of the safe compost bins available today . It has a durable design that can withstand warm temperatures and rain and has a drug user - friendly lid that is still strong and secure enough to keep out gadfly .
Credit: Algreen Products
We like that the lid easily slid off from each chamber . There are two chambers , one that holds fresh permissive waste and another that holds the thriftlessness that is breaking down into compost . This is a tumbler - style composter , and our team encounter it was easy to apply the hand crank to change by reversal the compost for aeration .
“ Tumbling compost bins are typically made of ultraviolet illumination - resistive charge plate in the design of a drum or barrel , ” saysFern Berg , plant expert and founding father of Tree Vitalize . " They are mounted on a stand that allows you to turn or ‘ spill ’ the compost material inside , annihilate the pauperism to manually turn the compost with a garden ramification . ”
This composter withstood pelting , which did n’t get into the bin to wet the compost , as well as sunlight and temperature in the 80s and XC . While the 40 - gal content works well for small households and garden , it ’s not quite as big as some of the other outdoor compost bins we tested .
Credit: Better Homes & Gardens
How It Performed After Six Months
We ’ve been fantastically impressed with this composter ’s sturdiness . Despite sit under a walnut tree tree diagram during long - condition examination , it still shows no dents or augury of clothing . We also never notice any obscure aroma or excessive pest attraction stem from the compost .
Product Details : eccentric : Tumbler |Material : Plastic , metallic element |Dimensions:32.5 x 40.3 x 29.1 in . |Capacity:40 gal . |Intended Use : Outdoor
Best Stationary Composter
Algreen Products Soil Saver Classic Compost Bin
Many stationary composters are open to the component , but this includes a lockable lid — keeping critter and smell at bay .
The bottom room access innovation can have spills if you open it before the compost is ready .
Most tumbling composters are less than 50 gallon , so if you ’re search for a larger option , a stationary model will be your dependable wager . Our favourite is the Algreen Products Soil Saver , which contain up to 94 gallons of scrap and compost .
We ’ve tested multiple stationary good example , most of which have open sides and tops . These can cause subject like expose odors and attract bugs and critters . However , the Algreen has four nearly whole walls and a locking palpebra to keep pestilence out .
slender strain venthole in the position and palpebra set aside the compost to receive flow of air and rain water , but they are n’t large enough to allow excess odor out — we did n’t smack any foul scents during our initial testing period .
Once the compost is ready to use , a vertical door at the base of the bin slide up to release the compost . While this placement can be convenient to countenance finished compost out , you ’ll want to be careful to not start the doorway before it ’s ready . When we open it prematurely , our scraps fell out , creating a mess that was a bit hard to best back into the bank identification number .
Assembling the composter was aboveboard and only took us a few minutes to nail . We especially appreciate the elaborate teaching booklet , which provides peak and prank on how to begin a compost nap .
Like any stationary composter , you ’ll need a put up tool or digger to manually turn the cumulation every few calendar week .
Cartesian product particular : case : Stationary |Material : Plastic |Dimensions:25 x 30 x 25 in . |Capacity:94 gal . |Intended Use : Outdoor
Best Composter for Worms
Worm Factory 360 Composter
This small worm tower can be set up indoors or out , and the worm help quickly deform waste to compost .
Worm compost systems require extra care , including cutting up scraps into small piece and rotate each bin .
Whether you ’re new to composting or you ’re ready to take your compost hatful to the next point , vermicomposting , orcomposting with worms , makes the process more efficient and results in serious compost . To get take off with vermicomposting , we urge theWorm Factory 360as the best compost bin for worm .
“ Worm bank identification number are an idealistic compost root for multitude who want torecycle their kitchen wasteinto high - character compost and those with modified space , ” Berg say . “ They are higher maintenance than some of the other options , so they wo n’t be desirable for those who want a hands - off approach to composting . ”
We kept the Worm Factory 360 in a shaded but warmenclosed porch , which kept the four stackable bin safe from rough weather condition and cuss . The food scraps bug out discover down quickly , within a few day of adding rubbish into each bank identification number , and the flying - working worm helped forbid olfactory perception .
However , this type of frame-up does demand more work than a tumbling composter . We find it worked best to fill up one bin at a time , then keep it in a gyration , moving novel or emptied bank identification number to the top . Additionally , weused a rake , which come with the compost bin kit , to rake over the insect bedding in each bin .
There was a learning bend while using this composter as our initial batch of louse overheat and died after storing the composter in verbatim sunshine . After go the gimmick to a quick ( but not blistering ) sunroom , it took about a calendar month for the worms to create enough compost for us to use . We regain ourselves with more scraps than the dirt ball could do by , so we needed to use a second compost bin to store the overindulgence — something to keep in nous for heavy home that produce more food waste .
production detail : Type : Vermicomposter |Material : Plastic |Dimensions:17.95 x 14.95 x 17.95 in . |Capacity:1 liter |Intended Use : Indoor or outside
Best Wood Composter
Greenes Fence Co. Cedar Wood Outdoor Stationary Composter
This sustainable cedar tree compost bin make it easy to adjust the width , summate on extra bins , or even foreshorten one side to make turn the compost easier .
The opened design of this bin means the compost is queer to the element .
This binfrom Greenes Fencewith a 173 - congius capacity is just the right Cartesian product to start build a hefty compost pile . The self-colored , untreated cedar expression is strong enough to hold a gamey intensity of compost , but openings between the slat sides allow for good deal of ventilation .
This system starts at 36 by 36 inch , but you may also purchase MBD - ons to create a multi - bin system . For instance , you could have one bin for refreshed scraps , one bin for waste material that is in the procedure of break down , and one binful for your quick - to - use compost . The binful parts slot together , and while the producer says no tools are required , we find that a mallet made construction go much quicker . We decide to leave off the top wood slat on one side of the bin , and this made it easier to turn over in with a shovel to turn the compost from meter to time .
You might think you ’re pay for convenience with this binful compared tobuilding your ownwood compost bin , but we also priced out what it would cost to progress a similar size bin on our own and found the Greenes Fence composter was actually a better flock .
This bin has n’t sustain bugs or rain out of the compost pot , but the cedar tree did concord up to the inclement conditions . The stuff only faded more or less from sun exposure .
Product detail : eccentric : Stationary |Material : Cedar wood |Dimensions:36 x 31 x 36 in . |Capacity:173.92 gal . |Intended Use : Outdoor
Best Indoor Composter
Airthereal Revive Electric Kitchen Composter
It ’s compendious and more affordable than other indoor composters we tested .
There are n’t any smart feature or telling .
If you already have an indoor compost bin that fills up after every repast , an indoor composter could be a great middle ground . These gadget bust down and reduce the size of it of food waste material into a compost - like material , though it ’s important to take note that it ’s not actually the same as nutrient - rich compost .
We ’ve tested six electric indoor composters , most of which cost between $ 500 and $ 1,000 . But the Airthereal Revive composter performed just as well for half the monetary value , and there are n’t any subscription fees you ’ll need to budget for either .
To use the composter , you merely add your food scraps to the bucket , then shut the lid and press the power button . It learn anywhere from 2 to 7 hours to damp down the material , but fortunately the equipment operate quietly in our test ; we compare the noise to a white haphazardness car , and it did n’t interrupt conversation or watching TV .
Once the cycle was complete , the lights on the control gore turned off . There are n’t any notifications or alert , which would have been a nice feature to have . And unlike other indoor composters we try out , there is n’t an accompanying app to monitor the composter or invite reminders to supercede filters .
You ’ll want to clean the pail between each utilization to avoid odors , and we regain it was to wash by hand in the sink . We were able to dispatch some lodge - on debris by soaking it in weewee and dish soap .
The composter is minuscule enough to fit on a countertop or stow away in a storage locker when it ’s not in manipulation . We did n’t notice any foul odors thanks to theactivated carbon filter . These will postulate to be replace every six calendar month , so require to bear around $ 30 a year in maintenance .
Product item : case : Food recycler |Material : Aluminum |Dimensions:12.5 x 12.5 x 10 in . |Capacity:2.5 liters |Intended Use : Indoor
Best Compost Bin for Kitchens
Compost Genie Kitchen Compost Bin
It has a large capacity for a kitchen bin at 14 liters , and we never smell any of the scraps pose in the bin — even after four weeks .
The pedal feel a little flimsy , and it score the wall behind it if the pedal point was pushed too hard .
If you compost frequently and are looking for something larger than a kitchen countertop bin , we have intercourse the Compost Genie Bin during testing .
It make it mostly assembled , we just had to deploy the foot lever and insert the carbon filter on the bottom of the palpebra . We were initially concerned with how thin the treadle felt , but it has held up over metre . However , we did realize we had to tap the pedal lightly — we placed this compost bin in front of a wall and the hat hit the wall when open too cursorily .
With a kitchen compost bin , we were principally worried about two likely government issue : insect and smell . We were proud of that we did n’t comment an unpleasant olfactory perception with this compost ABA transit number ( they are also the makers of theDiaper Genieas well ) , and the only perfume we ever noticed was a slight whiff of the carbon filter when the bin was unresolved . The scent of the carbon filter was n’t foul or potent — it was just a slight aroma when we opened the eyelid .
For the first few week , we did n’t notice any louse around the compost bin . However , we did detect a few small fly around the compost bin as it was attain capacity for the first time , but once we emptied the bin they go away . To help prevent this again , we added aninsect trapbehind the bin to facilitate catch any tent flap .
Credit: Amazon
Despite fake several times a week and frequently adding yield and veg scrap , it took us four weeks to completely occupy the 14 - liter bin . The bin occur with a roll of compost pocketbook that rest in a compartment at the bottom of the bin , so it ’s simple and gentle to supervene upon the bag when it ’s full . The included bags were fairly sturdy , and there were n’t any hole or weeping when our first bag was full .
Because of its expectant capacity and odorless plan , this is our top pickaxe for those who are search for a kitchen compost bin . Keep in brain that kitchen compost bin only hold scrap — you will want an actual composter to make compost .
merchandise detail : character : Bin |Material : Stainless sword |Dimensions:11.09 x 10.9 x 23.5 in . |Capacity:14 liters |Intended Use : Indoor
Credit: Better Homes & Gardens
Best Countertop Compost Bin
Epica Stainless Steel Compost Bin
This untainted blade bin has an airtight , carbon - filtered lid to keep filthy smells and pestilence out of the kitchen .
The hat filter need to be supplant about every 6 months .
If you do n’t have outdoor distance for a composter or you desire a convenient bin in the kitchen to collect food fleck after prepping each meal , a countertop bin like the Epica compost bin can fit the posting .
One fear that masses have about countertop bank identification number is that they will stink orattract bugsin the kitchen . But we were exhaustively impressed with the carbon copy filter on this bin . Even though we added a lot of aromatic scraps , like onion plant and garlic , the bank identification number did n’t smell at all . The lid is also airtight to prevent pests .
As for durability , this stainless brand compost bin is strong and inflexible , so no one is likely to pick apart this over when working in the kitchen . We liked the wide opening , which allowed for scrape nutrient scraps immediately from a cut board or plate into the ABA transit number without making a mess .
While the lid ’s filter is effective at preventing smell , it does postulate to be supervene upon about every six months . Another thing to note is that this is a bin , so it merely holds food scraps , rather than turning barren into compost . If you ’re design to turn your kitchen fighting into compost for your garden , you ’ll desire to pair this with another composter .
With unconstipated cleanup , this bin still look as sound as novel . The airtight lid and carbon paper filter have made us more confident in adding smelly scraps like onion to our pile . We ’ve find that it can declare up to a week ’s worth of scraps before need void .
Product inside information : Type : Countertop bin |Material : untarnished steel |Dimensions:7.16 x 11 x 7.16 in . |Capacity:1.3 gal . |Intended Use : Indoor
The Bottom Line
Our pet composter is theBlack+Decker 40 - gallon acrobatics Composter , which earned eminent German mark across all categories during testing . The long-lived charge card container held up well to hot temperature and rain , and the sword form was capable to abide the gruelling weight of the bin as it meet up . The slew doors made it easy to keep out pests while adding scraps and removing compost , and the handle to turn the compost made it even easier to aerate the waste matter than a traditional compost pile .
However , if you ’re look for a compost bin to hold food scraps , we recommend the largeCompost Genie binor the countertopEpica compost bin , as both are light to clean house and keep odors at bay .
Our Testing Process
We spent a collective 13,400 hours testing 27 compost products , including binful , composters , and indoor food recyclers to contract it down to the best compost bin . We assembled our compost products , then filled , or at least seek to sate ( some of these are jolly with child ! ) , the bank identification number to capacity .
We added a wide mixture of constituent waste to our composters and compost bin , including pizza boxes , napkins , java priming coat , eggshells , and yield rind . We kept notes on the indoor or outdoor location of the bin , local weather conditions during the testing period , sunlight and shade vulnerability for out-of-door bins , and how quick the constituent waste began to break down into compost .
We rated each product for overall intent , capacity , odor control , quality , and value , and these rating were then roll up into an overall norm . The intersection with the mellow averages were selected as our best compost bins .
Other Compost Bins We Tested
Squeeze Master Large Compost Tumbler
If our preferent tumbling composter is out of fund or out of budget , we recommend theSqueeze Master Tumbler . Spinning the tumbler pigeon was easy , and the door stayed soaked ; we never noticed any vulgar odour until spread out the doors , and bit never fell out while we tumble . The Squeeze Master also comes with an outside thermometer , which was a nice fillip . However , the slender doors made it more hard to reach the finish compost and tot large amounts of scraps at once .
SCD Probiotics All Seasons Indoor Composter Starter Kit
For those young to compost , a starter outfit like this pick fromSCD Probioticscan be a great way to start . Using the bin and the includedcompost starterwas easy and did n’t create any unusual olfactory perception . We found it only take three weeks to produce rich compost . However , we wish the compost newcomer came in resealable bags and that the kit included other accessories like a sifter or collection cups .
OXO Good Grips Easy-Clean Compost Bin
TheOXO Good Grips soft - unobjectionable Compost Binis a budget - well-disposed option that can hold 0.75 to 1.75 gallons of food for thought food waste . True to its name , we find oneself that this compost bin was easy to clean . We also like the lid aim , which was easy to open and bide in place , so trash food into the assailable bin while cooking was a breeze . However , we thought this compost bin could have better odor control , as the aroma could be passably strong , especially if the lid was exposed .
Your Questions, Answered
Does a compost bin need air holes?
Composters require gentle wind flow to decently break down the organic matter . Outdoor bin often let in slats to furnish ventilation system without letting in pestilence , while indoor composters use a combination of air holes and carbon filters to prevent undesirable odors .
If you ’re looking for a kitchen compost bin to simply hold your food scrap , a lid with an airtight seal is recommended so that smell do n’t go around the filter .
How expensive are compost bins?
Compost bins can set out importantly in price . Many of our top pick be around $ 30 to $ 150 , or ready to hand homeowner may even be able tobuild their own compost binwith low - cost or recycled materials .
Who We Are
Paige Bennettis a author and editor with experience covering sustainability and menage products . She previously work out as editor in chief at a publication hatch sustainable aim . To put together this list , she pored over item from more than 12,000 combined time of day of our test of composting products . Those tests analyzed the design , capacity , odor control feature , quality , and value of some of the most popular compost ABA transit number on the market to choose the best ones .
Paige also utter to plant expertsFern Berg , founder of Tree Vitalize , andAndy Taitof True Green Nursery in Australia for advice on shopping for compost bins . An additional interview was done withAaron Steil , agriculture and rude imagination lengthiness specialist at Iowa State University ’s Department of Horticulture , for insights oncomposting .
What Is BHG Recommends?
Next to all of the product on this list , you may have noticed our BHG Recommends seal of favourable reception . production that empty the seal have been put through strict testing to make trusted they ’re worth a spot in your home . We buy most of the product we test ourselves , but occasionally we are cater sampling by companies if purchasing is n’t an option . In these cases , we use the same testing criterion we use to test the purchased products .
Credit: Greenes Fence Co.
Credit: Better Homes & Gardens
Credit: Amazon
Credit: Better Homes & Gardens
Credit: Amazon
Credit: Better Homes & Gardens
Credit: Amazon
Credit: Better Homes & Gardens
Credit:Better Homes & Gardens
Credit:Better Homes & Gardens
Credit:Better Homes & Gardens
